By Wayne Adams
Last year over 100 Deerfield Beach city employees were laid off without any type of advanced formal notice, or may i say warning. Most people i knew were outraged, some of the laid off employees are still angry about Friday July 30, 2010. They have every right too, for they were never given this unique opportunity to bargain for their jobs.
The City of Deerfield Beach, in current contract negotiations is offering the General Employees a 3 year contract, with no layoffs or privatization with the exception of Solid Waste, Fire Department employees. In the third year Fleet Maintance could possibly be laid off. The Employees would have to take a 5% pay cut, rollback merit raises to those employees who received them in the last fiscal year, I'm being told that is about 38-50 employees affected. The employees must pay 10% towards now free healthcare insurance.
The financially strapped city hope to save $1.2 million annually. This city for years have slighted the general employees taking away from them and lining the Firemen pockets with gracious salary and pension benefits. For the first time in my memory, the city is looking for the same concessions from the firefighters, who are still in contract negotiations with the city.
The cuts are tough to absorb, I'm the first to admit that. But for city employees and some residents to imply that the IUPAT employees union have sold the membership out, is totally ridiculous at best. I have been on the negotiating team for 5 years, I have given my heart and soul for the employees of this city, but in these tough times when layoffs are occurring all over Florida, and across the U.S. Some Deerfield Beach employees, and residents are taking shots at this union, the union and their reps are always the easiest targets for disgruntled employees in tough financial crisis. This is the same union that got Deerfield employees 4% COLA raises for 3 years, when other cities were cutting back. The same union that got their part timers in Deerfield Beach benefits when some other cities deny their part timers any type of benefits.
Let's look at the sanitation/recycling, before and after layoffs only 9 out of 44 employees were union members. Many joined within the last 2 months only after the Florida Legislature threatened the existence of unions. IUPAT, has around 350 union eligible members in the unit. I was told the assessment report is in on the Solid Waste Department, the report I'm being told is in favor of keeping some functions of Solid Waste, and making some functions private. I think the level of service is excellent in Solid Waste and they should be retained by the city. We get the Cadillac of service with residential pickups.
I have always been cognizant of being a taxpayer and a city employee, it's a tough balancing act. The contract offered by the city isn't the best, but the majority of jobs will be saved. The employees this year have a clear choice with their destiny, the 100 or so employees last year didn't have a choice or chance to bargain for their jobs. What stands in my mind is 18 year former employee, William "Bo" Jackson, coming to me after getting laid off that Friday, the pain on his face, I'll never forget. I made a promise to myself, to never let that happen again if I'm a part of the union. The top union officials, who should be trying to advocate saving employees jobs are sending mixed signals to other employees by being quiet about the June 9 vote. They reportedly don't want to be perceived as giving in to management. The 100 or so city employees laid off last summer never had a chance to negotiate for their jobs.
I'm sure commissioners will sleep peacefully, knowing that employees were given a option this time around if layoffs occur. I'm hearing many employees in the excluded groups will vote no. It's like the "if I go down, everyone should mentality", that's spreading across the workforce.
In the past the blue collar employees wanted the same concessions from every worker, including management in the city, it was always denied. The management team granted the Union request after tense negotiations this year, everyone from the City Manager on down will take a 5% pay cut, and pay $30 a month for healthcare, that was once free.
My taxes on my home went from $1399.00 to $1735.00 in 2010. I can't afford to have another increase like that again. The city employees must understand that this city is in one of the worst financial crises, in my memory. I'm pro union, but I'm also mindful of the financial stability of our city. Some city workers seem to believe that the city has money stashed away. Some city workers and union officials want to roll the dice hoping that the City Manager Burgess Hanson won't layoff employees to close a $3 million gap. We saw what happened last July.
We saw DCF, give layoff notices to over 500 employees last week. We also saw the Broward County School Board hand out over 1,400 pink slips to teachers, with the Sun-Sentinel reporting another 500 supporting cast to be let go too. This budget crises isn't limited to Deerfield Beach, we know how the problem arose here with Mahaney depleting the reserves, but also saving jobs. Mike Mahaney came and talked to city employees in 2009, he warned all of us of the budget crises looming in the 2010/2011/2012 fiscal year. The Deerfield Beach city employees can act surprised if they want but Mahaney, with all his faults did warned all employees of this dreaded day.
It's too late to point fingers and place blame. The horse is out the barn and running around. We need a fix to this budget crises that has arose all across this country. The city employees can't win this battle like we did in 2003, with Larry Deetjen. The union took our fight to Arbitration, and lost, the commission was generous, all except Mayor Al, Trinchi led the way and we got our raises and COLAS retroactive too. The commission isn't on our side in this battle. I can count the votes. We had a majority of union friends on the Deerfield Beach Commission, those days are long behind us now. The contract offer on the table isn't the best, according to city officals, but it's the best they can offer at this time.
This contract has a reopeoner to bargain for wages before April of 2012, nothing is promised, but employees can attempt to bargain for wages before the end April of 2012. Employees who have been employed in Deerfield Beach, for over 17 years will tell you that this isn't the first time blue collar workers have been asked to have raises withheld. We worked with the city and no jobs were lost, in my memory this has happened at least three times in my over 22 years.
In tough financial times we have to pull together and hope not to become like the city of Lauderdale Lakes, who fired their City Manager a few weeks ago. The focus should be all about the well being and survival of Deerfield Beach, and not about some of our selfish greedy city employees, who could care less about the financial state of our city. Look at the city of Hollywood, their reserves dropped to $ 2 million dollars and forcing the city to declare "Financial Urgency" and asking the unions to enter into contract renegotiations. The Hollywood taxpayers will be hit with large increases.
It is also imperative that city leaders and administrators do not allow incompetance and mismanagement to continue to cripple our city, with no accountability and hefty raises given to cronies on the management team with no official oversight.
Property values dropped in Deerfield Beach by 4.6 percent. Most employees don't care about this city and don't live here so they could care less about the millage rate going up or down, or the thousands in this city living on fixed incomes.The only thing some employees care about is bleeding this city dry.
I've heard in recent days certain employees in certain departments are basically daring Burgess Hanson to lay them off. Some making foolish statements that they believe the City Manager to be making scare tactics of layoffs. This type of thinking is beyond my belief. Many are going around telling other employees to vote no on June 9. These are some of the same employees who gave up crucial benefits for a $500 bonus. Jim Jones and David Koresh led many people to their death, I'm afraid some employees, and some union officials are leading some city employees in that same direction with the ratification vote on June 9. This city has over 350 bargaining unit eligible union members. Most care about their jobs and understands the dire financial state of this city. Some just don't get it, and have their heads stuck in the sand.
With the budget hearings scheduled to begin on June 8, 2011 if this contract fails, I' m pretty sure the City Manager, with commission approval will possibly begain a repeat of July 30, 2010. The Union can't do a damn thing about it either, (oh, go to Impasse, we will lose that again too, and it will be imposed on us anyway) Last year union officials cut their phones off when hundreds of laid off employees begain calling. What do employees think will happen again? The layoff Arbirtration Hearing is Tuesday June 7, 2011.
So, why would anyone vote no on this contract ratification when jobs are clearly on the line? I've heard many theories, all absurd too. This union top priority should be trying to save employees from layoffs. The city, according to our contract, Article 4 section 1 under Management Rights: The city has the right to merge, consolidate or close a department or any part thereof; expand, reduce, alter, combine, assign or cease any job. How much clear is that for people to understand in the affected areas. Giving into the city demands isn't a sign of weakness as perceived by some in and outside of the city. It's being sensible in a society laced with unemployment. With Governor Rick Scott's new unemployment requirements, what fool would want to risk the chance rolling the dice and voting no on the contract ratification vote on June 9.
What this contract offer workers is protection from layoffs. The workers who are doing the jobs now will be doing the job next year. Ultimately, this union should be trying to prioritize job security, for which i haven't seen or heard yet. They seem to be bending over backwards to a few loudmouth employees, who are in every department. These selfish employees could care less if this city goes financially broke. In these moments of controversy, it's everyone responsibility to meet half way and get this city back on it's feet again. The employees didn't make this mess, but we have a moral responsibility to help clean this mess up.
I'm a 44 year resident of Deerfield Beach, and a taxpayer for the last 17 years who genuinely care about my community and it's workers. My family has resided in Deerfield Beach since 1926
Vote YES! on June 9, 2011 for IUPAT contract ratification. Vote YES! for common sense job protection.
'The Black Perspective'
Challenging Authority